|
Never Too Old
by Michael Clark Last week I was getting my monthly haircut and the familiar conversation started. “What do you do?” the stylist asked. “I’m a pianist,” I replied. “Oh, I always wanted to play piano, but I never started as a kid, and I don’t really have any musical talent.” “You can still take piano lessons now!” I protest. “Nah, I’m too old!” I hear this from hairdressers, dentists, church members—it is by far the most common reaction I receive when I tell people I play piano. I proceed to tell them that I teach several adult students, but they usually dismiss this, resigned to believing that for some reason they wouldn’t be able to succeed in piano lessons. What a tragedy! Music is not reserved for the young. It doesn’t belong to the rich. It’s not a secret only to be unlocked by a talented few. Music is for everyone. And now, more than ever, it’s accessible to adult beginners. |
Music Is for Everyone
Over the past decade, a new trend in music teaching has emerged: Recreational Music Making (RMM). More a philosophy than a specific method, RMM emphasizes that anyone can and should be able to make music in a supportive and student-centered environment. Teachers across the nation are embracing RMM and expanding the idea of what music lessons are and can be.
Traditional piano lessons are designed as a long-term investment, preparing students over the course of many years to play the works of great composers like Beethoven and Chopin. This format still works for many students, but not everyone aspires to this path. Some students want to learn to play hymns or to play the chords of a contemporary worship song. Others want to play songs they hear on the radio or learn how to write their own. The crucial element is that a student desires to make music of any kind. The RMM philosophy prioritizes the student’s individual goals, whatever they may be, and frees the teacher and student to find their own path toward that goal.
The RMM philosophy applies to one-on-one instruction, but it also flourishes in group settings. Group piano classes for adult beginners are popping up at music schools everywhere because they are an effective and engaging way to introduce basic musical skills. The social dynamic of small groups creates a sense of camaraderie around the shared learning experience. Group classes offer experiences that individual lessons can’t, such as playing duets and ensembles with the whole class and performing for your peers in a low-pressure environment. Classes like these usually move at a relaxed pace and provide practice time in each session, making them a great option for students who can’t spend much time practicing at home.
Teachers Like Adult Students
The RMM philosophy is flinging the doors of music schools wide open, but some adults still are reluctant to enter them. One misconception they may have is that adults are undesirable as piano students. On the contrary! Many music teachers (myself included) especially enjoy teaching adults. I’ve never once had to tell an adult to stop banging on the keys or to please follow my instructions or else we’ll have to bring your dad in here. Far from being a burden to teachers, adult piano students can be a welcome reprieve from the behavior management issues that come with teaching very young students. Adult students listen to teachers and can understand basic musical concepts more quickly than children, making them a welcome addition to a teacher’s studio.
Adults take music lessons because they want to, not because a parent has forced them. They also understand the cost of lessons, which motivates them to put in the effort to get what they paid for. Children can waver in their motivation for lessons, and they usually don’t understand that their parents have invested financially in their progress. The intrinsic motivation demonstrated by adult students frees teachers from serving as taskmasters, allowing them to focus their energy on helping students reach their goals.
Music Lessons Have Far-Reaching Health Benefits
As I so often hear from people I encounter, many adults don’t take music lessons because they think they are too old to learn a new skill. Not only is this false, it prevents them from reaping the many benefits of learning new skills later in life! The positive effects of music lessons for children are well known, but many of the same benefits apply to adults as well.
A 2006 study tested how piano lessons affected the cognitive function of older adults. The Florida-based study sought out healthy adults between age 60 and 85 who didn’t have significant previous musical experience. The participants completed six months of weekly individual piano lessons and were required to practice at least three hours each week (or about half an hour per day, six days per week). The participants were tested in a broad range of cognitive skills before and after their six months of piano lessons.
The adults who took studied piano showed improved perceptual speed and memory abilities compared to adults who hadn’t taken lessons. The study’s authors suggest that piano study likely increases “cognitive abilities related to attention and concentration, contributing to overall working memory.” Perhaps most interesting, the study found “significant gains in general cognitive assessments not specifically trained in individualized piano instruction,” meaning the benefits of music study extend well beyond the actual skills learned in lessons. Adults of all ages are limiting themselves when they decide they are too old for music lessons. The science says otherwise! Older adults are learning to play music for the first time, and it is improving their overall cognition.
The music teaching profession is changing. It’s broadening its focus and opening itself to everyone, young and old, with musical tastes of all kinds. So the next time you hear that song on the radio you wish you could play or give a haircut to an up-and-coming musician, don’t think that you’re too old to learn. The only thing stopping you is you.
1. J. A. Bugos et al., “Individualized Piano Instruction Enhances Executive Functioning and Working Memory in Older Adults,” Mental Health (July 2007): 11(4): 464–71.
2. Ibid., 469.
Over the past decade, a new trend in music teaching has emerged: Recreational Music Making (RMM). More a philosophy than a specific method, RMM emphasizes that anyone can and should be able to make music in a supportive and student-centered environment. Teachers across the nation are embracing RMM and expanding the idea of what music lessons are and can be.
Traditional piano lessons are designed as a long-term investment, preparing students over the course of many years to play the works of great composers like Beethoven and Chopin. This format still works for many students, but not everyone aspires to this path. Some students want to learn to play hymns or to play the chords of a contemporary worship song. Others want to play songs they hear on the radio or learn how to write their own. The crucial element is that a student desires to make music of any kind. The RMM philosophy prioritizes the student’s individual goals, whatever they may be, and frees the teacher and student to find their own path toward that goal.
The RMM philosophy applies to one-on-one instruction, but it also flourishes in group settings. Group piano classes for adult beginners are popping up at music schools everywhere because they are an effective and engaging way to introduce basic musical skills. The social dynamic of small groups creates a sense of camaraderie around the shared learning experience. Group classes offer experiences that individual lessons can’t, such as playing duets and ensembles with the whole class and performing for your peers in a low-pressure environment. Classes like these usually move at a relaxed pace and provide practice time in each session, making them a great option for students who can’t spend much time practicing at home.
Teachers Like Adult Students
The RMM philosophy is flinging the doors of music schools wide open, but some adults still are reluctant to enter them. One misconception they may have is that adults are undesirable as piano students. On the contrary! Many music teachers (myself included) especially enjoy teaching adults. I’ve never once had to tell an adult to stop banging on the keys or to please follow my instructions or else we’ll have to bring your dad in here. Far from being a burden to teachers, adult piano students can be a welcome reprieve from the behavior management issues that come with teaching very young students. Adult students listen to teachers and can understand basic musical concepts more quickly than children, making them a welcome addition to a teacher’s studio.
Adults take music lessons because they want to, not because a parent has forced them. They also understand the cost of lessons, which motivates them to put in the effort to get what they paid for. Children can waver in their motivation for lessons, and they usually don’t understand that their parents have invested financially in their progress. The intrinsic motivation demonstrated by adult students frees teachers from serving as taskmasters, allowing them to focus their energy on helping students reach their goals.
Music Lessons Have Far-Reaching Health Benefits
As I so often hear from people I encounter, many adults don’t take music lessons because they think they are too old to learn a new skill. Not only is this false, it prevents them from reaping the many benefits of learning new skills later in life! The positive effects of music lessons for children are well known, but many of the same benefits apply to adults as well.
A 2006 study tested how piano lessons affected the cognitive function of older adults. The Florida-based study sought out healthy adults between age 60 and 85 who didn’t have significant previous musical experience. The participants completed six months of weekly individual piano lessons and were required to practice at least three hours each week (or about half an hour per day, six days per week). The participants were tested in a broad range of cognitive skills before and after their six months of piano lessons.
The adults who took studied piano showed improved perceptual speed and memory abilities compared to adults who hadn’t taken lessons. The study’s authors suggest that piano study likely increases “cognitive abilities related to attention and concentration, contributing to overall working memory.” Perhaps most interesting, the study found “significant gains in general cognitive assessments not specifically trained in individualized piano instruction,” meaning the benefits of music study extend well beyond the actual skills learned in lessons. Adults of all ages are limiting themselves when they decide they are too old for music lessons. The science says otherwise! Older adults are learning to play music for the first time, and it is improving their overall cognition.
The music teaching profession is changing. It’s broadening its focus and opening itself to everyone, young and old, with musical tastes of all kinds. So the next time you hear that song on the radio you wish you could play or give a haircut to an up-and-coming musician, don’t think that you’re too old to learn. The only thing stopping you is you.
1. J. A. Bugos et al., “Individualized Piano Instruction Enhances Executive Functioning and Working Memory in Older Adults,” Mental Health (July 2007): 11(4): 464–71.
2. Ibid., 469.